Topic

If you did not know both parents and there is no scientifictesting to determine ithow would you beable to go about finding out if it was a Mule, (being from a male donkey and a female horse) or a Hinny (being from a female donkey and male horse). There is a way.
Kit and Mulereiner are correct there is no way without knowing the parentage.
Physical charactrics cannot determine
what it is.
Being Mules/ Hinny are highly intelligent.
In a test when knowing the parentage. A mule 9 out of 10 times will stay with horses and a hinny will stay with a donkey.
As animal do not see their reflections or go by physical appearence it is instinct. Interesting.

 

How can you tell if a it is a Mule or a Hinny

I agree with MuleReiner!
There is virtually no way of knowing the difference. I've known a lot of hinnys and until knowing the parentage there is pretty much no difference.
In fact, the ear size and hoof shape is so slight in most that
'a trottin' horse would not know' the difference.

 

How can you tell if a it is a Mule or a Hinny

It is virtually impossible to tell beyond a shadow of a doubt whether a animal is a hinny or a mule without knowing the parentage.

You can guess by taking into consideration the fuller tail, smaller ears & more horse like hooves which is typically a trademark but not a definate with hinnys.

I showed against a hinny that in every way resembled a mule. He was drop dead gorgeous, extremely talented & his parentage was known. He had the mule ears, mule hooves & mule tail.

 

How can you tell if a it is a Mule or a Hinny

WOW MAYBE I THINK HINNY

 

How can you tell if a it is a Mule or a Hinny

if its a mule it will look more like a donkey hinneys look more like horses..

 

How can you tell if a it is a Mule or a Hinny

Both would be sterile hybrids but the Hinny looks more horse like in the face and the Mule is totally MULE.

 

How can you tell if a it is a Mule or a Hinny

True there is no scientific way to test. Size does not determine either because the offspring could take size from either parent.
The only way we have been able to almost determine is putting them in with a female donkey and female horse. The one they gravitate was most like what its mother was. It only works when they are yearling. Much older then it is questionable.

 

How can you tell if a it is a Mule or a Hinny

''Hinnies r smaller because donkeys are, for the most part, smaller than horses, & equine offspring will not grow larger than the mother, in this case, a donkey, can accommodate. Hinnies do however, like mules, come in many sizes. This is because donkeys come in many sizes, from miniatures as small as 24 inches (610 mm) at the withers, to Mammoth donkey jacks & jennies that may be over 15 hands, approximately 60 inches (1524 mm) at the withers. Thus, a hinny is restricted to being about the size of the largest breed of donkey. Mules, however, have horse females as mothers, so they can be as large as the size of the largest breed of horse. There r some huge mules, mostly from work horse breeds such as the Belgian.

Other than size, there r some minor differences that occur frequently between mules & hinnies. The head of a hinny resembles that of a horse, more so than mule heads do. Hinnies often have shorter ears, although they r still longer than those of horses, & more horse-like manes & tails than mules do. They often come in horse colors, as the male parent often determines the color of the coat. Therefore, mules usually have donkey coat colors. Certain traits, like the popular gait that some horses & donkeys possess, seem to pass more readily though the male parent. Therefore, many people have tried to produce gaited hybrids by using gaited male horses on female donkeys in hopes of creating gaited hinnies.''

 

How can you tell if a it is a Mule or a Hinny

Well I am no expert and have never seen a Hinny but I know mules are larger-horse size while hinnys resemble the donkey more.